I'd give the slight edge to Uncharted 3. Obviously Uncharted 2 is superb and has the best word of mouth... I think UC3 is more of the same but polished in so many substantial ways. It was a much smoother fluid experience for me and I just enjoyed the pace. Until the end. I hated the end of 3. and I LOVED the end of 1 and 2... so that was my only let down with 3... Good OP though.. a good question to pose! Obviously opinions are going to differ greatly and many are still under the Uncharted 2 spell.. and for good reason. Hell I even love the 1st game!! I just loved the story of the first and the introduction of all the characters and how it was so full of jungle and tropical island settings.. But for this poll my vote goes to Uncharted 3.. it was more of the same with a ton of polish and the multiplayer was insanely deep and satisfying far more than UC2's MP which I also loved.







