Arkaign said: With an equal GPU generation, ddr3 is always slower than gddr5, by a fairly huge measure. Look up the benches of the 7750 ddr3 vs 7750 gddr5. The performance is off by 50%. |
Generation has absolutely nothing to do with it, you fell for the marketing, hook line and sinker.
DDR3 1333mhz on a 512bit bus is as fast as GDDR5 1333mhz on a 256but bus.
DDR3 1600mhz on a 512bit bus would thus by extension be faster than GDDR5 1333mhz on a 256bit bus.
Obviously you double the clocks for the DDR3 and Quaddruple the clock for GDDR5, but DDR3 can both be cheaper and faster than GDDR5 under the right circumstance.
Thus it comes down to implementation rather than memory technology.
S.T.A.G.E. said:
|
Nah.
AMD would have offered both companies their entire I.P of graphics and central processing units for use in the consoles, it was upto Microsoft and Sony to decide what they wanted.
Essentially though because Microsoft wanted 8Gb of Ram from the out-set they settled with DDR3 as it's cheap and plentifull, but in order to make up for the performance deficit by going that route they had to make up for it with eSRAM.
The eSRAM takes up a ton of transisters on the die, which drives up chip complexity and costs, thus by extension something had to give, which just happened to be the GPU.
Microsoft could have went with DDR3 on a 512bit bus which would have provided enough bandwidth, but that would have driven up PCB complexity and forced the use of a more transister-hungry memory controller.
Sony however, were origionally going to go with 4Gb of Ram, because of costs.
However before the consoles launch, higher density memory became available which made the upgrade from 4Gb to 8Gb actually feasible, it was a gamble that paid off and Sony should be commended for it, they didn't have to throw a beefier memory controller at the console, they didn't need more memory modules on the motherboard and it didn't drive up PCB complexity.
Over time, the Xbox's DDR3 is going to continue to get more and more expensive as the PC market shifts over to DDR4 and it's derivatives, the Playstation 4's memory however should get cheaper due to scales of economies, with a fast selling console and low-end PC cards starting to use GDDR5 more and more, production will be scaled up so all those devices will benefit.
On the flip side, Microsoft can take advantage of newer fabrication process's to cost reduce it's machine.
Essentially, there was no colluding or one company annoyed at another, just one company put the puzzle together better than the other this time, which is great for the consumer, competition is a wonderfull thing.
--::{PC Gaming Master Race}::--