An Unbiased Review: Titanfall

[Shinobi-san]

J_Allard said:

Shinobi-san said:
Hmmm you gave it a 10 for replay value...yet in your bad points you mentioned content might be lacking. I think you should neg a point from the replay value then. Perhaps make it a 9.

Considering the performance issues and the actual graphics...id put graphics at a 7 no?

All in all i felt your point allocation didnt match up to the words of the review. Reads like a 8/10 overall, great gameplay but lacking in other aspects. A 9 implies it is a shy away from perfection...and your review didnt read like that.

Just my opinion though Nice review and thanks for taking the time to write it!

The content there is enough for me and good enough to outweigh any negative about lack of content. And to me great gameplay trumps pretty much anything. So a high gameplay score will merit a high overall score. There is a lot of room between 9 and 10.

Yeah i know you have your reasons. I wasnt trying to change your opinion. But i was giving you my opinion on your review. Feels like the scores and the words didnt match up. Happens quite often with reviews.

Although i do worry about your statement in your reply " great gameplay trumps pretty much anything. So a high gameplay score will merit a high overall score." which means you might as well have not mentioned the other aspects. It implies you would have scored the game higher regardless of any other shortcommings, which  I dont agree with personally. That being said its your review and you can do whatever you want with it.

Edit: Shortcommings in aspects other than gameplay* ofcourse. Which might be a valid point, thats a whole other discussion on its own though.