EDGE gives Yoshi's New Island 4/10 [62 on Metacritic]

[MikeRox]

Mr Khan said:

Honestly i was never that jazzed by the original Island either. I was very "meh" on it when it came out on GBA, which is odd because i LOVE Yoshi's Story (could be an issue of nostalgia filter, but i feel the game holds up much better. Could be i'm a sucker for branching-patch platformers with an exploration element)

Surely it's a bannable offense even for a mod to say such blasphamy? :P

Yoshi's Story was a travesty in comparison to Yoshi's Island!!! Though those singing Yoshi's were just so adorable that you could forgive them enough to justify the £49.99 price tag :D eeeee eeeeeh ooooooh!