Which game will thrust you into the next generation?

[Brii]

I already have a Wii U, but for the other two, it would either be the elusive 'Last Guardian' if it jumped gens, or a slew of my favorite genres, like rpgs, or really unique games. I've always been of the mind that I refuse to buy a console until the amount of personal must-have games equals the value of the console itself. I can't justify to myself paying more for the box than the games themselves, since I really only use consoles for gaming. I would NEVER buy a console for one or two games. It's too much of an investment with too little payout.

Unfortunately, I don't count FF XV and KH III as 'must haves', since I've honestly never been a fan of either series, even though rpg is my genre of choice. And shooters, third person or otherwise, are rarely enough to entice me, though I have enjoyed the Bioshock series and Left for Dead multiplayer despite being awful at both.

Also, as strange as it seems, ultra realism is a turn-off for me, as I don't find it aesthetically pleasing at all. I have a tendency to overlook anything that looks too brown/gray and gritty when scanning video game news sites. I might be a hard sell this gen.