Leadified on 23 January 2014
Deadly Premonition - I blame the bad box art for the bad reviews
Halo Wars - it actually controlled very well and overall really fun
Age of Empires II: HD Edition - Other than the netcode being totally horrid and the misleading name (should've been called Widescreen edition), most reviewers complained on how HD it wasn't, gave it a 5/10 and called it a day.
