1. Castlevania: Lords of Shadow - Mid 80s avg, deserves 90%+
2. Alan Wake - Mid 80s avg, deserves high 80s
3. Resistance 3 - Mid 80s avg, deserves high 80s
4. Bulletstorm - Mid 80s avg, deserves high 80s
5. God of War: Ascension - Low 80s avg, deserves mid 80s
They're the first 5 games that popped into my head.