By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
Soleron said:
pauluzzz1981 said:
...

maybe, but einstein had some crazy ideas for his time. We will see. What is in your opinion the biggest assumption in science that is sometimes stated as a fact?

The Riemann Hypothesis.

Unproven mathematical conjecture that a lot of papers in the field assume to be true before writing anything.

Sorry, but this is my area, and no one I know states the Riemann Hypothesis as fact.  Mathematicians by training have pretty rigorous standards for what they are willing to call a fact.  However, being creatures of abstraction not bound to the real world, we are still happy to write speculative papers built on the premise of RH, which are clearly labeled as being conditional and not factual results.

A slightly better example from math would be the Axiom of Choice.  Again, you won't find a mathematician who claims it as fact, but entire areas of mathematics would be unusable without this assumption (the effect is large enough that you wouldn't routinely call out the use of AC unless you were addressing a wider audience).  Even still, operating in this way is pretty credibly justified by Gödel's and Cohen's consistency results (we essentially know that AC will never be proven or disproven in the future, not without taking down some more fundamental axioms).