1 - Elfen Lied
2 - Serial Experiments Lain
3 - Ah! My Goddess
4 - Fairy Tail
5 - Tenchi Muyo
6 - Fate/ series
7 - Queen's Blade
8 - Neon Genesis Evangelion
9 - Dragon Ball
10 - Narutaru
A fairly even split between niche thinking stuff and comedy action, interestingly. No number ten I didn't watch up to ten animes in my life. Not most of them, anyways, though I remember glimpses of Naruto, InuYasha and Saint Seya. Also, did Pokémon count? It was pretty good before Black & White IMO.
Edit - I did watch ten, I just forgot I had. Narutaru. God damn Narutaru. Just thinking about it gives me the creeps.