42. Sonic Adventure (last year 44), first impression 8.5, replayability 8.5, technical 6
Pros: prequel to Sonic Adventure 2 (no spoilers, my number 2 now and in previous years), keeping much of what made that game great, including the glorious treasure-hunting and the just-right balance of platforming and acrobatics that made the Adventures the best of the 3D Sonic epoch. Fun with treasure-hunting, too.
Cons: Fishing and lots and lots of glitches, even in the remastered GameCube version that i played (can't imagine what would have gone down in the DC version)
Monster Hunter: pissing me off since 2010.