Time and time again, I've seen high profile games score consistently high regardless of quality. GTA IV is a prime example of that. That game could bore me to death, and yet it had scored 10s everywhere. Then there are games like Too Human on the X360, which I enjoyed massively, yet every "gaming journalist" buried that game.
I couldn't care less about what gaming media has to say anymore.
(A bit off topic... but anyway!)







