So, I didn't really grasp everything written in the OP, but I'll try my best.
First, I think the criteria you listed is a bit off. Instead of graphics, physics, audio, controls, and story, I'd suggest graphics, play control, game design, sound, and presentation.
Second, just because a game has more content doesn't mean it's better. A tacked on multiplayer mode offers very little value. In some cases it actually detracts from the overall experience.
Thirdly, multiplatform games typically receive identical scores because in most cases the differences are immaterial. When the differences are noticeable the game that performs or plays better usually gets a few extra points.
I would add, finally, that we should all use Metacritic as a general guide and not as gospel. My advice, as always, is to find one or two reviewers you trust and follow them.
Existing User Log In
New User Registration
Register for a free account to gain full access to the VGChartz Network and join our thriving community.
