There are 2 "new" entries on my list this year, that is, games that I purchased from last November through the deadline this year, but a number of old games, under my new system of evaluation, clawed their way up, 5 games total were eliminated from the old 50, so 3 games became big winners under my new system, here I list the 5 that fell:
1) Bomberman 64: Last year 31, under the new system, it ranked 74th of 75 candidate games I evaluated (only EarthBound was weaker). It lost due to cheap-o difficulty in the single player and the kind of bad production values that plagued early N64 games, as well as the fact that it took a long time for me to really figure out the game against more intuitive games on the list
2) Goldeneye 007: Yeah, i know, sacrilege. The multiplayer was never really sacred to me (i was never any good at Goldeneye's multiplayer: always got beat). The replayability of the single player was its only saving grace, as it was a game I was slow to warm up to initially, and the game too suffers from production values problems. Last year it was 23, this year 64 of 75 games evaluated, tied with Metroid II, Kirby's Return to Dreamland, and Toe Jam & Earl
3) Wii Sports Resort: What hurt the game's chances was the "objective score", not because it's poorly-designed per se, but just because I didn't enjoy about half the sports (wakeboarding and especially basketball come to mind). It was 34, now it's in a multi-way tie for 58th place, along with two other games of the Loser Five, plus No More Heroes 2, Mario Kart DS, and Kirby Air Ride
4) The Last Story: A game that wowed me effectively in the beginning (part of why it made the list last year), but that i don't have much desire to replay, and was only good, not great, on a technical level. Last year 47, now tied with Wii Sports Resort and number 5 on this list
5) Super Mario 3D Land: The first half of the game was too easy by far, which left me feeling underwhelmed out of the gate. It had a very strong late-game, but not strong enough to bring it up. Tied with Wii Sports Resort and The Last Story (and others), old rank 49
Monster Hunter: pissing me off since 2010.
