The Top Ten Games of the Generation

[Nem]

Gamer_of_the_Year said:

Nem said:

Errr... NBA 2K11?! That is ridiculous, sorry to say.
I have reservations on God of war 3 and Uncharted 2 in comparison with their sequals.

I would love to make a top 10 list, but its far too early. The generation is still gonna last a couple more years and theres games i'm looking forward to next year and others from this year i havent played yet.

I could say some of the game that would probably be there. Mass Effect 2, Fallout 3, Tales of Vesperia, Nier.

Ummm...the greatest sports game of the generation being on a end of the generation list is ridiculous? Even if you don't like sports or sports games objectively you have to marvel at the attention to detail and the labour of love for digitally recreating basketball as faithfully as humanely possible NBA 2K11 and so on are...

In all honesty your post is the ridiculous one good sir....

Oh really? Why dont you tell us how the gameplay improved compared to the past generation. How engaging the setting is, how inspiring the score is, how griping the storyline and the characters were.

No, a sports game is far from beeing digital art. Improved graphics dont make a good game.