By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
ironmanDX on 21 October 2013
Edit Thread
thismeintiel said:
ironmanDX said:
thismeintiel said:

Actually, it doesn't hide supply. If they both sell out, but one finishes higher, then obviously the higher one had more supply.  It also shows demand. If one finishes higher and sells out quicker, not only is there more supply, but there is also higher demand.  We also have the leaked Gamestop memo that points to this exact scenerio. Sorry, but you don't go from launching in 21 countries to just 13 because you have the same supply as the guy launching in 31 countries.


If it all sells out then demand was there to sell more...

 

Especially in the biggest markets. So yes, it's possible.

I would like to know how you guys continue to do that.  ALL the evidence (preorder positions, Gamestop memos, MS dropping from 21 countries to 13 because they obviously don't have enough supply for 21) points to one thing being the truth, yet you take the same info and somehow come to the exact opposite conclusion, that MS has the same supply as Sony, maybe more.  Like with TheSting, there's no point in continuing this conversation.

Evidence? Hardly.

 

It's more like a connect the dots game but I do see your point. My point was it can't be completely ruled out. I said it's POSSIBLE. I didn't say MS had produced more or less. With all your evidence you actually know as little on the situation as everyone else here. We all have to wait for the official numbers.