Gamecube/360 design is the best. Simple ergonomics logic. Plus PS controllers "highlight" the DPAD even tho its almost unused today.
Sony never thought about the analog as the main input because it was just tacked on to the original PS1 controller design. Its like "where to we put this we have to have the same thing the N64 has! lets put it here" compared to the "lets make a controller from scratch that uses logic and laws of ergonomics. = GC/360-design".