Do Brand name games get inflated scores based on hype?

[binary solo]

think-man said:

ListerOfSmeg said:

think-man said:

ListerOfSmeg said:
Oh it happens. Just look at GTA4. I don't know how many but a few reviewers came back after the fact and said they regretted scoring it so high.
I am not sure how anyone can say Nintendo games though. They are judged harsher than any other company.
W101 for example. I read 3 different reviews that said the game would be AAA if it was on PS3 or 360 but because it was on Wii U it was docked points.

Where did you read that? Id like to read those reviews.

The Wonderful 101 had a lot of potential, but by being a Wii U exclusive and forcing the implementation of the GamePad and touchscreen that potential was squandered. It’s a bitter pill to swallow, but the Wii U’s latest exclusive game is made worse by being exclusive. - See more at: http://stevivor.com/review/wonderful-101/#sthash.GUDA9wim.dpuf

Looking for the other review now where the reviewer says exactly "Had it been on any other platform it would have been a quality title", but it takes a while to go through them honestly. Took me about 30 minutes of backtracking to find that one.

Cheers, guess he doesn't like touchscreen, he's gunna have a hard time gaming in the future as it seems to be an "In" thing atm.

Not on Xb one or PS4 it's not. And clearly the market is speaking atm and telling Nintendo that the tabletcontroller was a mistake. Though 2014 may be a turnaround year for Wii U, who knows.