While I still can't make a complete assessment yet (since I haven't tried Grand Theft Auto Online yet), after playing through Bioshock Infinite, The Last of Us, and Grand Theft Auto V at least once each (recently finished GTA V's single player campaign), my personal vote for Game of the Year is currently going to The Last of Us. Despite the sheer amount of content in GTA V, After finishing it, I strangely didn't have as much desire to replay it, unlike TLOU where I immediately did another playthrough on survivor (I stopped playing Infinite midway through my 1999 run).
It could still change, depending on how GTA Online turns out (as well as Beyond: Two Souls), but for right now, TLOU has my vote.







