Which plays the biggest part in a game becoming memorable, its graphics, story or gameplay?

[SSJGohan3972]

These are my 7 favorite games of all time (not necessarily in any order), the games that I usually replay at least once a year.

Final Fantasy Tactics
The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past
Super Mario World
Pokemon Silver/Soulsilver
Civilization 4: Beyond the Sword
Super Smash Bros. Brawl
Dragon Ball Z: Legend of the Super Saiyan

definitely gameplay for me. pretty graphics are nice but will eventually be old, nice story is great but once its a replay I already know the story, the best games, the ones I want to replay again and again are fun to play just because they are fun to play.

Also for people talking about music, I love some of the music in video games but once I've heard it a few times I tend to mute it (I've played handhelds on mute since the gameboy, started because I was playing around the family and they didn't want to hear it) it's nice but again just a secondary to good gameplay for me.