Which plays the biggest part in a game becoming memorable, its graphics, story or gameplay?

[snyps]

For a first time purchase it's all about graphics! But you ask what makes it memorable...

Games are living art. I like to replay my favorite games again and again every few years. Good Graphics don't hold up over time. Good Gameplay never gets old. A Good Story loses its surprise. My imagination can make up story and visuals. But the gameplay needs to be solid and addicting for me to wanna play again and again.