I understand your point, golfgt170 , I see that the number of reviews recieved may distort some of the scores. A game with very few reviews may get a low score just because among those reviews a moron rated it very low because he doesn´t like the type of game. (this is clear with the JD4 example)
I just believe that the discrepancy comes more from the excessively focus on personal tastes than on technical achievements/features when reviewers do their "job". This gets even more clear when games have more than 9 or 10 reviews.








