By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

SM3DW has a good chance of reaching a high rating, probably over 90. DKC TF should be pretty close to Mario, though if the visuals don't improve, then I wouldn't place it with Mario. Wind Waker could make it as the highest, but I don't know if reviewers would consider the game to be rated the same as the original. Sure it's in 1080p with lighting and stuff, but the geometry is almost exactly the same. I expect lower ratings than the original due to the fact that it wasn't a complete remastering of the original. Sonic? Lol no. The Sonic team could never make a console Sonic game to be rated in the 90s, which the other 3 have a good chance of making. So no, Sonic is not an option, kind of laughable to even consider it.

Some guesses:

SM3DW - 92
DKCTF - 90
WWHD - 93
SLW - 81