I only read the first few pages of comments here but the general consensus seems to really be against it. However, I not only think it's a great idea but it actually looks pretty good as well.
First off, as the Kotaku hands-on stated, it seems like it would be infinitely more comfortable than a standard 3DS. I love the XL, but using the d-pad on the regular 3DS is painful in lengthy durations. This design provides enough plastic below the d-pad to get a comfortable grip and the buttons look great as well. I just wish it had a more ergonomic curvature to the shape in the back (more similar to the WiiU Gamepad).
Secondly, think about how well this will go over with kids. It's durable; there's no fragile hinges, there's no 3D eye-strain for youngsters and the price is perfection.
For me personally? I think I'm going to get one eventually. I'm still looking forward to getting a 3DSXL first but unlike many people here I don't think this is ugly at all. In fact, I actually like it. I just wish it had the XL-sized screens, but with its "slice of bread" shape, that would make it a bit too large, I suppose.
