Mafia Round 58: Avatar The Last Airbender

[Linkzmax]

Vetteman94 said:

Linkzmax said:

Miller strongly implies there is a Cop as Tracker and Watcher are unaffected by a Miller.

Let's try this again shall we. Night 1 Noctis visited me and I visited Nacho. Noctis is confirmed town, to me at least, due to his role, not mine.

A Tracker and a Watcher can still be useful for a Miller as a tracker can see if he goes anywhere,  and if a Watcher saw me show up at a persons house my Miller claim would be BS as I dont visit anyone.  Plus I never said their couldnt be a Cop,  just surprised at what seemed like alot of investigation roles coming up.   

You've played enough games to know that a Tracker is normally accompanied with a Watcher,  for me to make that assumption is not unfounded.  And to add a Cop also to that mix seems excessive regardless if there is a Miller or not, given that this game is only 13 people.   

Fine,  I was assuming Noctis to be town anyway.  

Now you're looking at it backwards. Miller is a counter to Cop as it gives them a false positive. The way you're talking about a Tracker or Watcher is in terms of busting a fakeclaim, which isn't a false positive. And I never said you didn't say there could be a Cop, but for your theory of there being too many invstigative roles it's quite suspect that you didn't assume there to be one, making the count even higher.

I've played enough to know that while it's not unusal to have both a Watcher and Tracker, it's hardly the norm that the existence of one implies the existence of the other. On the other hand, it's practically a gaurantee that a Miller means there is a Cop.