Mafia Round 58: Avatar The Last Airbender

[Yoshiya]

Vetteman94 said:

I was only role fishing for the people who seemed to be claiming they had knowledge on others alignments.  Because it seemed we had an abundance of investigative role for the town.    Thats why, but it has been clarified for me.   I was only questioning the exsistence of the number of investigation roles it seemed we had.   As I said to Linkz,  it is normal for a Tracker to be paired with a Watcher, and there are uses for it against a Miller.  What wouldnt be normal is adding a Cop.  Now its possible a Cop would replace the Watcher,  but its not the norm.  Which is what I am basing my situation on.  Maybe like you said the Watcher part is actually replaced by a JOAT, which includes cop ability as well.  

My vote on morenoingrato is pretty simple.  I took what everyone was saying as far as who they believe was town/had a high chance at being town and eliminated them from the list of people left.   Took the people left and analyzed their posts, he came across as the worst of whats left. Mainly because 2 of them werent posting at all at the time.  He seemed quick on the defensive and had no good explanation to the situation, he just agreed with other people instead of trying to look for something himself.  Plus he has now basically disappearred probably hoping people would forget about him and focus on other people.

The latter part was more aimed at Nacho but thanks for the response anyway, at least it seems you have legitimate reason for going after Moreon at the moment, just a shame I don't believe you are on the right side atm.

I think in a power heavy game it's best not to assume that a certain side doesn't have certain roles, unlike the normal games you've played, a game like this is supposed to have an abundance of roles afterall. That said, the main thing I find weird is not the questioning of the number of roles but rather the questioning of the type. Unless Mario is a bastard host, roles like Miller will only be included if there is a cop (although including Miller makes him a bastard already :P) so why did you jump on the idea that out of the trio of investigative roles, the cop (the role that would need to be present for your role to make sense) was the one that wasn't in the game? It just doesn't seem right to me.