How does one do an RTS title on the XBOX ONE?

[endimion]

richardhutnik said:

endimion said:

theshonen8899 said:
They would need to dramatically change the controls similar to Pikmin. Currently implementations (Kinetic, Smartglass, whatever) will not be able to emulate PC controls well enough to be fun or playable.

I don't agree voice control and motion control combo would easily do the trick....

say : "select all units" "attack closest ennemy unit"
say: "build command center" then either position it with your hands or smartglass
say: "create group one" and then select with hands or SG

etc etc.... I actually would love to see that on PC too.... real commanders don't point and click on units... they give out voice orders...I'd love to see a really well done voice supported RTS (yeah I know there have been tries in the past)

but being able to say
tank units, hold the line at rally point alpha
GI's flank the ennemy group in zone delta by the east, fall back if you reach 50% casualties
Comandos go on hill side zeta and wait for my orders
engineers get ready to be air lifted at LZ tango
etc etc

One can go and try End Game to see how it goes.  The number of units commandable is much smaller.  And RTS fans just don't get into it.  Idea here is to be able to get PC RTS stuff able to also appear on consoles in a way that is natural.

I know but it was total crap and has nothing on the kinect capabilities.... this is prime exemple of Devlopers doing the voice control work with regular mics themselve having nothing on the kinect capabilities and on board API they can use freely with 0 or close to overhead..... this prove exactly the "you can do voice command with a regular headset" rant against kinect is just as solid as wet paper windows in a wind storm

and I have played probably most major RTS... from Warcraft to most c&c, close combat, total anhilation and its mods, halo wars, Starcraft and so on

and I'm sorry but every crew, guild or whatnot I have been in are dreaming of something else than point and click (yeah sure competitive play will probably always be better that way, but once again the core of the hardcore is not what makes profit for a dev) they have wet dreams of the day they will be able to handle battle like you see on TV shows like battle star galactica scenes in the CIC...
something like the RUSE commercial and End Game way better capabilities would be awesome on console.... if you want a PC experience on console buying a console in the first place is stupid anyway....IMO