By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
Vetteman94 said:

OK lets get a rundown of the current situation.  

There are 10 people left 

Yoshiya
Linkzmax
Trashleg
morenoingrato
benao87
Nachomamma8
Astrogamer
Vetteman94
Noctis_Nox
Baalzamon

Yoshiya 
Claimed to be at Stefls the night he was killed,  but claims he never did it.  But has been cleared as town by what seems to be a Jack of all Trades Astrogamer. No one seems to be contesting other than myself so I will let it go. Probably Town

Linkzmax 
Was visited by Noctis, and Linkzmax visited Nachomamma8 on night 1. With everyone having power roles it seems, this is probably quite common.  But was that scenario completely confirmed? Claims Noctis_Nox is town, how he knows this hasnt been explained.  Because Nachomamma8 isnt dead, we could assume that Linkz is town.  Was the purpose of your visit ever explained? No word on what he did night 2 

Trashleg 
Hasnt been on for over a week.  Probably Mafia, should be modkilled. if replacement soon cannot happen

morenoingrato 
Not much for participation, especially in day 1. Believes there is a Godfather in this game because of the flavor.  Seems to believe Doctor prevented night 2 kill, which is probably what happened, but acted almost bitter about it.  "Doctor had good timing it seems"  Strong Possible mafia.

benao87
Was not really ok with lynching spurge, believed he was acting suspcious but not too out of the ordinary. Not much on day 2.  Possibly town/possibly Mafia

Nachomamma8 
Visited by Linkzmax on Night 1, not dead but that only bodes well for Linkzmax.  Seemed to defend the extra kill on night 1 by using flavor to try and point out it was with good intentions. Voted Astrogamer right out of the gate for day 2, no unvote due to no post since reveal.  Possible Mafia/Possible Town

Astrogamer
Seems to be a Jack of all Trades or at least a hybrid role of Cop and Watcher. Has cleared Yoshiya. High probability Town.  

Vetteman94
Claimed Town Miller, some suspicions early on about claim but those people are oddly dead now. Most believe roleclaim, althought I am sure there are still many doubts.  Should have been killed by town vigilante if there really is one to avoid possible confusion later on in game since the possibility of a mafia kill is unlikely. Cause why would they kill someone who claims a role that is most fake claimed by Mafia.  Which is one of the reasons I believe it was a SK and not a Vigilante.

Noctis_Nox
Had suspcions of morenoingrato on day 1, but voted for spurge.  Jumped on Yoshiya on Day 2 and had suspicions for Astrogamer. And also broght up the possibility of a Mafia Strong Man, not sure if this means Godfather or something else. Linkzmax claims him to be town. Not much for participation.  Probably Town.  Would have to believe Linkzmax to think he was 100% Town

Baalzamon
Same as Trashleg basically,  Little to no participation.  Probably Mafia, should be modkilled if replacement cant be found soon


So if we take people at their word(at this point what other option do we have) and what other information we have.  He is what the probable mafia list looks like.

Trashleg
morenoingrato
benao87
Nachomamma8
Baalzamon

After going through the game a second time and then a third time.  I am thinking morenoingrato is a good choice for lynch today.

If anyone sees any errors please let me know.  

Your error is being suspicious for erm... not being cheerful enough about the doctor saving a kill? Seriously?

Your other 2 Mafia members are those who have hardly participated. Your arguments are based on believing in what other people claim.