Yoshiya said:
You claiming the Earth King or....? |
Yoshiya said:
Why would we need to do that? If Mario has done this game properly there should be no way to manipulate the characters since their rules etc. won't be linked to their character. In fact, I'm so confident of that I'm going to name claim now: Toph Beifong (a blind earthbender of exceptional skill) |
So here, Yoshiya is town not only for reading faaar too much into flavor and helping stefl figure out what character he has, but Yoshiya is also town for the nameclaim and the way that he went about it. It's putting himself out there in a way that's unlikely to be coming of scum. I do NOT think Stefl looks that great from the exchange. Stefl doesn't know what character that he is and he doesn't care to check, which seems like something that is more likely to be scum rolling with a scum fakeclaim that was practically fed to them as opposed to town who forgot his role PM and somehow never goes back to check.
Stefl1504 said:
LOL anyway, anybody is getting the feeling that spurge is tryharding? |
Not liking his either. For one, there is no reason to appeal to everyone else instead of confronting spurge himself, and for two, spurge's meta assertion that Stefl usually attacks him as scum is interesting and should earn a response from town Stelf regardless of its validity, but instead Stefl ignores it and keeps pushing spurge as scum, which is the kind of thing which speaks for itself to me.
| AstroGamer said: Who hasn't checked in yet? So far I think we can trust Yoshiya's name claim and no one seems too suspicious yet. Stefl is behaving pretty much like he has in previous games and his behavior isn't the best indicator of his alignment especially in the beginning of a game. |
Why did you say this with regards to Stefl?
| Stefl1504 said: And Vote: Spurgeonryan stop tossing stuffz around! |
The tone on this is so off that I have trouble interpreting it as serious.
| Final-Fan said: Not sure how I missed benao's post, lol. I swear I thought that was an original thought when I was typing it. |
Surprisingly enough, I found this to be an extremely genuine post from FF. If he was scum, it would be even more unlikely that he would post the same thought that benao did, and the way that this happened makes me think that it wasn't faked.
Stefl1504 said:
Because I am pretty sure he is town. |
Stefl is avoiding questions, dancing around giving reasoning... almost certainly mafia at this situation.
| Yoshiya said: Stefl is acting weird but there is some roles that can explain how he knows that Linkz is town and they are ones that I know he wouldn't want to announce right now. On the otherhand, why say he knows Linkz is town in the first place in that case? I agree that he is acting very strangely but I don't really think mafia Stefl would act this awkwardly for no reason (afterall, most of the stuff he has said, he's done off his own back rather than because he's had to) |
The problem is that his weird read doesn't extend to Linkz, it extends to everyone. No reason to give him a free pass for a PR claim that you're seeing and not
one that is really really real.
| spurgeonryan said: Unvote Vote: Nacho He agrees with me, and he is lurking, and he goes after linkz. He knows that linkz is one that you want to get out of the game early on. Plus no one is voting him or mad that he has not shown up. Dismayed, but not mad. |
^Spurge regarding me agreeing with him as a scumtell is so town that it's making my eyeballs pop out.
Stefl1504 said:
In regards to your inquiry that I should answer your question... let me answer this with: I never said you were afraid of it not to happen. You just deemed it less likely to happen, thus you moved on. Scum doesn't care who to mislynch as long as a mislynch happens (in earlygame that is). |
Extremely hyporitical, considering you're willing to push on spurge like crazy without giving anything for reasoning.
| spurgeonryan said: ^ remember the ones who voted for me tonight. maaybe protect linkz. leave noctis alone. and trash for now. look into benoa, is astro playing? if so him, and nacho or final fan. if it is truly a power game this should be doable in some way. |
STEFL confirmed scum. Cop linkz, don't protect him because he's probably scum. Don't have a handle on the third scum, but STRONG town are vetterman, yoshiya, spurge, final-fan.
