A Muslim writes about Jesus - Is This The Most Embarrassing Interview Fox News Has Ever Done?

[ultima]

ListerOfSmeg said:

ultima said:

No, the gospels contradict themselves. A lot. They also contradict a lot of the scrolls that didn't make it into the bible; and there's a lot of inter-contradiction within those manuscripts. The upshot is, the bible simply cannot be true.

Because it was written by different people with different opinions in different ages it simply cant be true.. Thats not only a silly reasoning but it shows a complete lack of understanding on how society can change. My God dude you are on an internet forum where few people if ever agree 100%.

I guess in 1000 years Sony couldnt have ever existed because not everyone has the exact same opinion about them....

I'm talking about fallacious contradiction. You're using the word contradiction very loosely if you consider two people disagreeing (as in subjective opinions) to be contradiction. The different books of the bible contradict each other's recounts. This means that if you accept one to be true, then the other MUST be false.

That said, my comment was in response to the previous commenter claiming that the gospels make perfect sense. That's simply not true.