Argument from nonbelief

[Soleron]

Jay520 said:

Soleron said:

It's more that, even if you got them to admit a logical contradiction on some point, their belief in God is more fundamental than that. Those capable of being persuaded to nonbelief already would have, or have social reason not to [surrounded by less than tolerant believers].

I'm actually not trying to persuade anyone. I was just wondering if people thought the argument was sound.

Any thread like this, whatever your purpose, gets out of hand quite fast.

fwiw your logic is sound and the definition of perfectly loving is what's up for debate.