I still have my Edge copy from the Ps3 release. At the time they compared it with the Wii due to both releasing in the same week. They are harsh but fair and in the end of the article this comes along
"it's a tall order, but what Wii and Ps3 have on their side is time. With Wii's distinct identity, and Ps3's bottomless potential, both leave the 360 feeling like the last of the old breed."
I do think these guys should be hired to make box-art, they've made some nice covers through the years. ;p