| JWeinCom said:
|
Not really. Comparing classic cel animation to polygon based CGI work, is about the same as trying to compare sprite based graphics to polygon graphics. It's pointless. Two different things. Muramasa: The Demon Blade was hands-down MUCH better looking, as far as straight-up visual beauty goes, than most games on any console or PC last gen. But that's apples and oranges, because that was hand-drawn sprites versus polygonal graphics. In my personal opinion, the best looking sprites are always going to trump the best looking polygons.
On the same token, even the best CGI film couldn't really be "visually superior" to Fantasia, because Fantasia was and is a drop dead gorgeous piece of painstakingly crafted, loving made hand drawn masterpieceness. 3D can't be "superior" to 2D, because they're two different things. I get what you were trying to say, and that you weren't personally saying Croods WAS superior to Fantasia. But I just thought I'd throw that all out there anyway.
