This is why Playstation Plus is better then xboxlive!

[Dr.Grass]

MB1025 said:

It will be on the PS4, but as of right now one is for the entire online echo system and the other is an added service. Once we get to next gen and if Microsoft keeps the 2 games a month then we can have this debate. Until then they are 2 different things.

However lets look at it like this.

In July I can download Halo 3 and AC 2. If I stop paying for live I keep those games.

If I stop paying for plus tomorrow I am locked out of everything.

Now you can talk about how much value you have gotten since 2010, but again we are comparing a service from 3 years ago to a service that hasn't even started yet. And on top of that we don't know if Microsoft is keeping this service on the Xbox One. This could be a trial run for something bigger or it could just be a thank you to players before a new generation and we never see this again.

I'll agree with you that (at least at this point) it isn't as clear-cut as some would lead one to believe.

If I were to make a counter argument, it would be that H3 and AC2 can be picked up for almost nothing 2nd hand.