Dahum on 27 June 2013
it comes to my surprise that no one ever mentioned Heavy Rain as one of the contenders!!
for me i will rate them according to the WOW factor that i had with them in no particular order:
God of war 3
Uncharted 2
Heavy Rain
Castlevania: Lords of shadow
Resident Evil 5
Killzone 3
Uncharted 3
Dante's inferno
Prince of Persia: the forgotten Sands
Heavenly Sward
