Jessman: 9, like the colorful background a lot
Goosegaws: 7.5, plain and simple
AoA: 8, uploading that okeydokey folder somewhere will get you a 10
kirby: 8, nice picture and I like how you arranged the desktop icons around the wave so you can see it still
Neos: 8.5, that bg seems to go well with the vista theme
rdbraptor: 9, nice theme and icon arrangement
finalsquall: 8, can't see it well but the bg looks nice
sherlock: 6.5, nice picture but negative points for AOL Trial membership 
routsounmanman, 8.5, real nice picture, just seems crowded with icons + can't read some of your folder names 
WoW: 8, nice and serene
ssj12: 9, I like the background and you get an extra point for all the torrenting
LISMDK: 7.5, is that the Windows classic theme?
Soriku: 6, cute wallpaper but organize the desktop a little
tehsage: 10, usually i'm not a big fan of pictures taking up just a part of the background but that pic rules!
..
And for my own...
