Shouldn't success be measured by the games?

[naznatips]

NeoRatt said:
Boy everyone is really rambling today...

This is a no win thread... I am with Legend that games are the most important part of a console.

And it is clear that when you go to metacritic and gamerankings 360 is ahead in all categories except in "Mario" games. Sports games have rated high on 360, RPGs rated high on 360, JRPGS really only exist right now for 360, FPS rate highest on 360, 360 is the only one with RTS games, etc.

If you choose to use Gamerankings as your medium, PC wins nearly every genre. However, if you want to stick to home consoles, the highest rated games in these genres disagree with you:

Platforming: Highest rated game, Super Mario Galaxy, winner: Wii

Adventure: Highest rated game, The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess, winner: Wii

Puzzle: Highest rated game, Zack & Wiki, winner: Wii

Sports: Highest rated game, NHL 08, winner: PS3 (the second place is MLB Power Pros. on Wii, so you lose either way).

Nothing wins all genres. Hey, you've got FPSes and WRPGs right?