5/10
Positives:
A solid focus on games. No talking about Kinect. Games Games Games
The Witcher 3 gameplay
Dark Souls II
MGS V (cautious about this one)
Project Spark
Neutral:
Games didn't really show how they can be much better from the X360 outside of more fps.
Titanfall. It looks intriguing, but it clearly is a online game and that didn't make it stand out too much.
Halo....something
Quantum Break
Negative:
Not too many "mindblowing" blockbusters that the XOne direly needs, or any rather.
$499 price point. Seriously, did you learn nothing from Sony?
Lack of information on DRM
Cartoony games taking a huge focus
Lack of Japanese titles
Not a bad show, but not great either. A missed opportunity really.