By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
Daisuke72 said:
TGM said:
All im going to say is that everything Retro touches turns to gold. Naughty Dog not so much.

Judging by how most of you post, and your track records I wouldn't doubt if you guys have ever played the Uncharted series and simply posted to support your favorite IP, which is ridiculous when you consider this isn't even a comparison thread. Also, I find it very hard to believe someone was able to beat the first Uncharted, but couldn't finish 2 because it was less interesting? I'm sorry but I find that very hard to believe, 2 was simply the better game in every way. 

 

Also the Metacritic for Metroid Prime 1: 97, Metroid Prime 2: 91, Metroid Prime 3: 90. Average = 92.6. Sales: Less than 9M.

 

Uncharted 1:89, Uncharted 2:96, Uncharted 3: 92. Average:  92.3. Sales: More than 15M.  

 

They're both critically acclaimed studios. The fact you guys are arguing which one is better is silly to me when most of you are bias towards the IP on your prefferred console. No matter how good Metroid or Uncharted is you guys will simply downplay it if it's not on your console, I simply can't believe anyone could call these two studios overrated. It's annoying that EVERY thread here ends up in a console wars bias debate. 

Retro

 

Prime 1

Prime 2

Prime 3

Prime Trilogy

Metroid Prime Hunters

Half of Mario Kart 7

Donkey Kong Country Returns

 

 

 

Naughty Dog

 

Keef the Thief

Rings of Power

Way of the Warrior

Crash Bandicoot

Crash Bandicoot 2: Cortex Strikes Back

Crash Bandicoot 3: Warped

Crash Team Racing

Jak and Daxter: The Precursor Legacy

Jak II

Jak 3

Jak X: Combat Racing

Uncharted: Drake's Fortune

Uncharted 2: Among Thieves

Uncharted 3: Drake's Deception

Jak and Daxter Collection

The Last of Us

 

Lets start with Retro.

Yes, they have only made 7 (6.5 really) games that made it to stores. Every single one of those 7 mentioned above are top notch games. They all look well, play well and sell well (considering the console/fanbase of dk/metroid/kart). That is what i mean when i say 'everything retros touches turns to gold.' As for Naughty Dog, they are NOT a shit company that makes shit games. I have tremendous respect for their games (especially TLoU) because 8 out of 10 times they pump out incredible games...but they HAVE made some pretty bad ones. Retro hasnt YET and thats why i think they are the better company at making games. This isnt really a big deal imo.