motion controls, will they ever appeal to the "core" gamers?

[bananaking21]

Angelus said:

All I can tell you is that core gamers aren't as opposed to motion controls as you think. I'm friends with dozens of gamers in real life and they all enjoy playing some motion controlled games now and again, and are all hopeful that they keep advancing in a positive direction moving forward. These kinds of forums, and internet communities represent a minority of players, most of which are the super "geeks" so to speak, who are dead set in their ways, and oblivious to what's actually happening in the real world.

 

Fact is, motion controls can be a lot of fun, and are recognized as such by MANY core gamers. Do they get as hyped about them as regular games? No. Do we play them as often? No. Are they technically as good/high quality as regular games? No. They are however, on occasion, a fun change of pace, and they do have their appeal. Even to the core gamers.

i think you are really misunderstanding me. im not motion controls dont appeal to gamers or that they dont enjoy them. yes there are a lot of core gamers who enjoy motion controls, i didnt say otherwise. but really is the percentage of those who do enjoy it a lot? not really. the support and type of games that companies make kind of shows it. games like GTA, assassin's creed, dark souls, far cry and many many others have nothing to do with motion controls. they are just not wanted in those games. 

i made a thread to ask a question, could motion controls ever be as popular or almost as popular as standard controllers withen the core gamers? yet a lot of people decided to be extra defensive or aggressive in this thread