By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
dsgrue3 said:
Talal said:
Like Jay520 said in his thread, "bigger" is a vague term. However, in this gen Halo did better in more criteria's. So if I had to choose I'd say Halo.

Except the OP specifically mentions All-Time, which would incorporate this gen as well as all previous gens...rendering your analysis obsolete.


Oh, I missed that. If it's all-time then yeah GT wins.

 

Edit: actually it's still very hard to decide, but I guess this time GT wins in most criteria's so it is bigger.