Gran Turismo vs Halo Which Is the bigger 1st party exclusive?

[sales2099]

Subie_Greg said:

sales2099 said:

Subie_Greg said:

sales2099 said:

Subie_Greg said:

Mr Puggsly said:

Subie_Greg said:
GT is more important to Playstation then Halo is to Xbox. GT is bigger than Halo

Nope.

Not only has sold significantly more units in recent years. But it made Xbox Live a very successful service even before CoD was a mega hit.

Nope

GT5 has sold more units than both Reach and Halo 4. And is only about 1 million short of Halo 3. Halo is a shooter, and not even the biggest shooter on the Xbox

"Which is the bigger 1st party exclusive". Halo sold more this gen, brought in more $$$ this gen. That about answers the thread. Simple. 

So Guitar Hero is bigger than GT?

lol i like your deflection. But even though you are trying to make a joke, you have a point. 

Which IP brought in more $$$$ this generation? Guitar hero was a multiplat, and also a annual release. So really, its no contest. I know it sounds crazy, but "ganging up" is a viable tactic. It shows how much people are willing to come back time and time again and fork over their money. 

If Halo is a bigger franchise than GT soley based on $$$$ because of more games is gen then Need For Speed is bigger than GT.

Compare GT5 to any single Halo game in total sales. 

Comparing random IPs isn't getting you anywhere. The question is what is bigger.....$$$$ is the only logical way to determine. Offcourse Need for Speed is a bigger IP....it too is multiplat and a annual release. 

Your argument is referring to 1 vs 1. The major flaw is that it isn't the full picture. You must compare all games, as is the thread title. I use this gen only as it is current and gives a accurate picture of current levels. That means comparing every GT and every Halo this gen.