I would say either FarCry 3 or Tomb Raider (2013). As I said in the review I feel like 3rd parties such as these has surpassed 1st parties in graphics although they aren't talked about as much.
Know what you guys should start doing in your reviews? You should start highlighting certain parts of the reviews, you know, where the punch lines are or something like that... Some sort of summeries that convays what you're saying in a shorter way. And perhaps have some sort of + and - system with things that were good/bad...
I really wanna get my hands on both TR and FC3 some day!
I'm on Twitter @DanneSandin!
Furthermore, I think VGChartz should add a "Like"-button.