Xbox Live adds 6 Million members in a single Year, is the hate unjustified?

[Ostro]

Chark said:

The difference between XBL and other services is not a car to a bike.

$3 a month isn't either.

The majority of people who speak out on the internet are those who have to criticise something. Positive opinions are (more) silent. There are many reasons why. So even if there are 100,000 users who don't like it (of which most likely 50% favor Sony but own a 360), there are still millions of happy users.