(Updated: GoW wins - Both bad) Sales - God of War Ascension vs Gears of War Judgement

[wilco]

CGI-Quality said:

JayWood2010 said:

 Weirdly I think most Gears fanatics will say that Gears 1 was the best because they have the fondest memories in it whether it be from nostalgia or they genuinely feel that way.  Gears 1 had more problems than the other 2 but it weirdly connected with people regardless.  They definitely made an addicting multiplayer for all 3 that requires skill rather than point and shoot, but they are all different than one another and all have their own problems.  The only problem that seems to have stuck for all three was getting stuck on walls  and sponging haha  

Put it this way, in Gears 1, it wasn't about the prettiest weapon, armor, or ribbons. It was all about raw, competitive game-play. Calling it "merely nostalgia" is a cop out. It worked, despite its problems. In fact, all three games had their issues, but the freshness of the series was lost in the fray of its sequels. Not to say nothing good came from Gears 2 or 3, but they also divided a lot of the franchise's veteran fans, which is unfortunate.

Now, all that considered, I don't think Gears 3 gets a lot of the credit it deserves. It was much more like the original than Gears 2, particularly with the return of the wall-bounce, faster Gnasher, and speed of the combat.

Gears 2 didn't have wall bounce? Gears 3 took its wall bounce from gears 2 not gears 1. It also took its shotty from gears 2 (center screen vs barrell shots). Are you sure you've even played gears 2?