By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
pezus said:
BloodyRain said:
Did anyone find it weird that the guy from the nights watch, john snows friend was still alive in season 3? When I think back at the season 2 finale, it looked like that guy was a goner with all those white walkers.

I think how they handled that first scene (or just the Fist of the First Men in general, i.e. the ending of season 2 and beginning of season 3) was far inferior to how it was in the book. Sam killed an "Other" by himself. Really wonder why they changed that, as it was major for his character development

Yea I was upset when he didn't kill an "other" in the first episode.  Been a while since I read the books, so I thought maybe it was because he killed one later and I was wrong about when.

But it was just dumb.  He had a perfect oppertunity to kill one when that stragler came, and yet was the stragler even an "other" or was it just a whight?  Looked like a wight to me, and due to being killed by fire.   

They shoudl have had it be an "other" and let Sam kill it and and kill it with dragon glass as well.  no Idea why they changed it.  There was easily a scene they gave that let it happen, yet they changed it.  Very strange.

Also why did they make it so that Sam didn't send out the ravens.  He in the books managed to send a message

 

They took Sams awesome moments and made him into a total failure.