By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
Talal on 15 March 2013
Edit Thread
curl-6 said:
Talal said:
curl-6 said:
JayWood2010 said:
curl-6 said:
So because you don't agree with them, they should be disqualified?


As i stated before it has nothing to do with me disagreeing.  It is about how unprofessional these reviews are.

Looking over their Journey and Halo 4 reviews, they don't seem any less professional than most game reviewers. Just more opinionated.


But he has to be objective with certain aspects of the game like controls, music, presentation, graphics, online etc. There is just no way Halo 4 deserves a 20 no matter how much he didn't like the game. Reviewing (at least professional reviewing) can't be just about whether you liked the game or not.

His Halo 4 review makes logical and reasonable points. I may not agree with him, (It's an 8/10 to me) but nothing about it is less valid than the plethora of 9/10 reviews for the game.


It would have been fine with me if he at least gave it more than 50. 20 is just too cruel imo.