Sal.Paradise on 15 March 2013
I don't care about the scores a publication gives, and it's ridiculous to ask for outlying scores to just be discounted. What does matter though is the content of the review, and I remember reading their Journey review and it displaying about the level of analysis and communication I'd expect to find in a middle school student magazine. So that should discount them from the site.
Then again, there are plenty of positive reviews where I could level exactly the same criticism. So the best idea is to not bother with metascores whatsoever.
