Devil May Cry 4.
I was so amped for it after playing 3, one of the best games of all time IMO. And after I got it, the first couple of months I completely glossed over it's flaws because of how great the combat was. Looking at it now, though, the story was half-baked, the new characters were annoying, and the constant backtracking and recycling of stages and bosses was lazy bullshit.
While it wasn't as dull as 2, it didn't even deserve to shine 3's shoes.








