It's the type of game that some people love and some people hate. I don't see a problem with that. It happens.
I read a lot of reviews about ZombiU because it's one of the few Wii U games that really interest me, and I actually thought the disparity made sense. From what I remember, almost everyone had some issues with the game, but for some the atmosphere and vibe made those issues inconsequential. For others, those issues ruined the entire experience.