Vote: Top 5 New IP's of the generation

[Jaywood2010]

pezus said:

JayWood2010 said:

pezus said:

As I was saying...CoD and Gears can not be compared. CoD is a monster for a reason, and everyone wants to be that monster.

im not argueing that call of duty isnt as influential as gears and never have.   They both have been and you can argue the two all day. You are making an argument out of nothing.  I said gears is more influential than uncharted.  

Wut, no you didn't. You began by saying Gears was the most influential game this generation. Then you said Gears and CoD were comparable when people mentioned CoD being far more influential.

I do feel that gears is the most influential but I can see the argument behind call of duty as it is hugely influential as well and Ive said that multiple times i believe.  I mean i could go back in check that, but Im pretty sure ive said that multiple times in this thread.  That is why i said it is arguable as you can make a case for both games.  Other than that Ive been mostly been talking about uncharted and gears and I hate doing that kind of stuff since they are both my two favorite games this generation.  I cant really say bad about either one of the games but I have a hard time sitting here listening to people say that uncharted had more influence than gears. 

And as others mentioned you can argue the same about wii sports.  I think you may have been one of them actually?